The recent lawsuit alleging that a toddler was returned to an ICE detention facility during a measles outbreak forces us to confront a deeper moral question: What kind of nation are we becoming?
When children are frightened during enforcement raids—awakened by armed officers, separated from parents, or confined in unsafe conditions—the damage extends far beyond a single moment. Medical and psychological experts have long warned that such trauma can shape a child’s entire life. To then place a toddler in a facility facing a contagious disease outbreak raises serious concerns about both public health responsibility and basic human decency.
This situation also begs a profound question: If the great moral and religious leaders who shaped our world—figures who preached compassion, mercy, justice, and protection of the vulnerable—arrived at our borders today as strangers, would they be welcomed? Or would they be turned away?
The central teachings of Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Sikhism, and other faiths emphasize care for the child, the stranger, and the oppressed. These traditions remind us that how we treat the most vulnerable is a measure of our moral character. History, including the painful legacy of apartheid in South Africa, shows us the lasting harm that occurs when state power is used in ways that dehumanize families. Leaders like Nelson Mandela demonstrated that true strength lies in justice and shared humanity.
Children are not political pawns. They are human beings deserving of safety, dignity, and protection—regardless of their immigration status.
Yet, our government designates white South Africans as an oppressed minority and grants them favored status, while subjecting Black and Brown immigrants to treatment that many describe as harsh, intimidating, and deeply distressing.
I respectfully urge you to support a full investigation into this matter, ensure stronger safeguards for minors in custody, and reaffirm policies that reflect our highest moral principles rather than our deepest fears.
The question before us is not only legal—it is moral. And history will remember how we answered it.