Bret Stephens, a former editor of The Jerusalem Post, again rushes to defend Israel while ignoring the catastrophic suffering inflicted on Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank. Any honest discussion of morality must also confront mass civilian deaths, widespread destruction, starvation, illegal settlement expansion, and repeated attacks by violent settler extremists while Israeli forces often stand by.
Human rights groups and international observers have also documented abusive treatment of Palestinian detainees in Israeli prisons, including allegations of torture and sexual abuse that demand full independent investigation and accountability.
History did not begin on October 7. The creation of Israel in 1948 was accompanied by the violent displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians during the Nakba, carried out in part by Zionist paramilitary groups such as Irgun, Lehi (the Stern Gang), and Haganah.
Stephens also ignores that Jews, Christians and Muslims lived together in relative coexistence in Palestine before partition and the violent creation of the Israeli state. It is therefore no surprise that Israel’s actions in Gaza have led growing numbers around the world to view the country as morally isolated and condemned for what many legal scholars, human rights advocates and governments describe as genocidal crimes.
True moral consistency means valuing Palestinian lives as equal to all others, condemning atrocities regardless of who commits them, and rejecting the dehumanization that fuels endless violence.